Remember when you were a child and some kid with a really big mouth blabbed to you that there was no such thing as Santa Claus? Well, sorry, but that was me. I didn’t mean to ruin your Christmas fantasy, to make you cry, or bring you down on Christmas morning. It’s just that when I figured it out, I thought you’d want to know. I thought that “The Adults” were trying to pull something over on us and it didn’t seem right. At the time, I didn’t understand that Christmas was way more fun when you believed in the magic of Santa. Learning the truth so early made me a skeptical kid, and sadly, my skepticism continues today.
I don’t remember the back story entirely–what made me question Santa’s existence–but somewhere around the first grade I got suspicious. Unfortunately, my mom wasn’t the best at hiding gifts or bluffing, for that matter. So when I stumbled upon an unwrapped Suzy Homemaker Oven in her closet, right in plain sight, I immediately smelled a rat. When I confronted my mother, she toppled like a house of cards. She didn’t even try to convince me there was a Santa. And I was only six years old! (The whole idea of sex she tried to hide from me but believing in the magic of Christmas? Forget about it!)
I wasn’t always so cynical. I do remember a time when I did believe in Santa. I remember staring out the window from my bed on Christmas Eve trying to search for Rudolph’s red nose. I remember heading to New York City and hoping I wouldn’t pee when I sat on Santa’s lap at Macy’s . I remember the nervousness on Christmas morning wondering if Santa had come and if we walked into the living room would we catch him in the act? In those days, Christmas time was always filled with whimsy and wonderment.
I miss those days.
But in life we do get a second chance to try and repair some of the faults of our own childhoods by doing things differently when we get to be parents. Since I’ve always felt bad that I was the neighborhood Scrooge I’ve gone to great lengths to keep the Christmas fantasy alive with my own boys, and as far as I can tell, it’s worked.
Sure, I’ve used the usual bag of tricks like wrapping Santa’s gifts in different paper, and even having someone else write out the gift tags so my kids wouldn’t recognize the handwriting. And no one can hide a gift better than me, stashing many inside old suitcases that lay dormant in the garage. But if they were to give out an Academy Award for the Best Portrayal of a Parent Answering Kids’ Questions About Santa, I’d win hands down.
Earnest and straight-faced, I’ve given a four-star performance as I’ve answered a barrage of questions like, “Why do some kids get way more gifts than us?”
Easy. I send a note every year to Santa telling him about our family values and which gifts are appropriate and which ones are not. That also explains why my kids don’t receive the violent video games that they put on their yearly lists, too.
But last year when my boys skepticism was rising, I had a stroke of genius. As we were heading out to mass on Christmas Eve, I pretended that I had forgotten something in the house. When I ran back inside, I quickly placed Santa’s gifts under the tree (I had moved them from the garage into my bedroom that afternoon while they were off doing something else) and then raced back to the car. When we got home that evening, the boys walked into the room to discover that Santa had come! Their gasps of disbelief were audible. Totally priceless.
Kids grow up way too fast these days. They see the harsh realities of life that we were immune to as children just a few decades ago. So if I can keep my boys believing in miracles and magic for just a few years longer, than I think my job as a parent has been well done.
Merry Christmas.







